A Sermon Delivered
by
The Rev. John D. Painter
at
Centenary United Methodist Church
Metuchen, New Jersey
October 16, 2005
(Stewardship Sunday)
Text: Matthew 22:15-22
Then the Pharisees went and plotted to entrap him in what he said. So they sent their disciples to him, along with the Herodians, saying, “Teacher, we know that you are sincere, and teach the way of God in accordance with truth, and show deference to no one; for you do not regard people with partiality. Tell us, then, what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?” But Jesus, aware of their malice, said, “Why are you putting me to the test, you hypocrites? Show me the coin used for the tax.” And they brought him a denarius. Then he said to them, “Whose head is this, and whose title?” They answered, “The emperor’s.” Then he said to them, “Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” When they heard this, they were amazed; and they left him and went away. —Matthew 22:15-22 (NRSV)
I’m holding a quarter in my hand: Twenty-five cents. “Big deal!” you say.
If you have any quarters in your pocket or change purse right now, it doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out how much they are worth. Whether you call it a quarter, two bits or a 25-cent piece, each one is worth 25 cents. In some places, five of them will still get you a cup of coffee, 10 of them a mocha latte…maybe. It’s for darn sure “two bits” won’t still get you a shave and a haircut, however!
But there is a slight chance that you might have a quarter worth as much as $1,500.
The new quarters being issued these days are part of the “50 State Quarters” program. Beginning in January 1999, the United States Mint has, every 10 weeks, released a new quarter celebrating one of the 50 states, and they have been doing so in the order that the states were admitted to the Union.
Thus the first quarter that was issued honored the state of Delaware, and the final coin in the series, to be stamped in August 2008, will celebrate Hawaii. The quarter I have been holding is a New Jersey state quarter, issued in 1999.
Things have been going along fine, but in October 2004, when Wisconsin’s coin was put into circulation, coin collectors across America sat up and took notice.
The reason? Minting errors. Every time the mint produces a new quarter for a new state, it makes about 500 million of them, and sometimes mistakes are made. Normally the quality-control procedures at the mint weed a lot of those out, but in the case of the Wisconsin money, some error coins got by, and they have one of two kinds of blunders.
The state side of the perfect quarters has the head of a cow, a wheel of cheese and an ear of corn bursting forth from the husk. On one of the error coins, however, the version numismatists call “extra leaf low,” there is a little mark on one side of the corn ear that appears to be an additional husk leaf half peeled off the ear. The version of the mistake the collectors have dubbed “extra leaf high” is much the same, except that the shadow “leaf” is not peeled quite as far from the ear.
Anyway, because only a few of these minting errors made it into circulation, collectors are eager to get their hands on them. So if you find one in your pocket or your piggy bank, you might get anywhere from $150 to $1,500 for it. Believe me, I am encouraging our counting team members to carefully peruse the coins in our Barrel Offerings from now on!
Actually, minting errors are not all that rare in the money that reaches the public, and the Wisconsin quarter is hardly the only flub in our coinage. Go into any coin shop and you can see several examples of minting-error coins, in denominations from the penny to the silver dollar. The fact is that the U.S. Mint, between its Philadelphia and Denver locations, produces billions of coins every year. They are struck at the rate of nearly 10 coins per second, so many that visual inspection of all but a few is impossible. There is some machine sorting, but mistakes do get out there.
Our New Testament reading puts before us today the incident where some influential men who were opposed to Jesus tried to set him up for big public embarrassment and destroy his credibility.
In front of a crowd—perhaps equivalent to asking him on a live TV news conference—they asked Jesus whether it was lawful to pay taxes to the emperor. Their devious idea was that if Jesus argued against the tax, they could accuse him to the Roman governor of urging rebellion against Rome. On the other hand, if he endorsed the tax, the common people who hated their Roman overlords would likely view him as sympathetic to Rome, and thus turn away from him. For Jesus, it was—they thought—a lose-lose situation.
Unfortunately for them, they had no plan when Jesus turned their question on its head, and that’s exactly what he did. Calling for his challengers to produce a coin of the realm, Jesus asked them whose head (Greek: eikon “image”) was imprinted on it. After the challengers gave the obvious answer that the image was that of the Roman emperor, Jesus instructed them to “Give therefore to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s, and to God the things that are God’s” (Matthew 22:21b, NRSV).
Jesus was telling his audience that day about a kind of minting error that they could make with their money. In fact, he turned the whole incident into a teachable moment in which he reminded them that they should be as attentive to their responsibilities toward God as they were to their obligations as subjects of the empire.
Since we are followers of Jesus today, it is therefore worth asking what sort of minting errors we make with our money and the things we possess.
One way to frame our answer to Jesus’ show-me-a-coin question is that it is not our likeness that appears on our money. In the ultimate sense, which is the sense that Jesus’ question was really about, whatever we have is not really ours. All things come from God. Forgetting that is a minting error.
There is an old story that illustrates how easy it is to deny that what we have comes from God. A prosperous farmer was miserly in what he gave to his church. So his minister went to visit him in hopes of getting him to increase his giving. The minister pointed out to him that the Lord had given him a fertile piece of land and had blessed him with sunshine and rain so that his crops would grow. The preacher added, “You know, this farm and everything you have is really on loan to you from God. You should be more grateful.”
The farmer replied, “I don’t mean to complain, Reverend, but you should have seen what a mess this place was when God was running it by himself!”
Can’t you sympathize with that farmer? Theologically, the preacher was right that everything we possess comes from God, but we tend to believe that our prosperity has more to do with our work ethic and a good college education than it does with a theological idea.
There is a natural sense of pride we feel when we have accomplished something that makes us reluctant to share the credit, perhaps even with God. But to say that all things come to us from God is to acknowledge that behind everything is God. Without God’s grace, blessings and mercy, we literally could not exist. God is, in the ultimate sense, the monarch of our world, and we make a minting error when we think that we do not owe God the coin of God’s realm, which includes such things as vision, risk and hope and results in our commitment, gratitude and generosity.
An Old Testament story gives us a healthy perspective on that. The last several chapters of 1 Chronicles contain the record of King David’s preparations to turn the leadership of the kingdom of Israel over to his son, Solomon. The last two chapters include David’s instructions to the people to help Solomon with the building of a permanent temple to house the worship of God.
Up to this time, the center of Israel’s religious life had been the tabernacle, the portable tent which the children of Israel had carried with them during the 40 years of wilderness wanderings following the exodus from Egypt. Once David had consolidated the kingdom of Israel and had established his capital at Jerusalem, he decided to build a glorious and permanent structure to replace the tabernacle. But then God forbade David to do this, but had told David that the son who succeeded him to the throne would be the one to build it.
David therefore did the next best thing. He gathered all of the materials needed to do the job. He contracted with skilled craftsmen to serve his son. And he donated not only income from the royal treasury, but also huge sums from his personal fortune as well.
Finally, he challenged the people themselves to offer not only their skills and talents but also their offerings to the task that lay ahead. The people responded in both ways generously.
Chapter 29 in 1 Chronicles contains the prayer of thanksgiving David prayed after the people joyfully made their commitments. It is a very humble prayer to be prayed by a king, and in it he cautions his subjects to avoid a couple of minting errors.
For one thing, unlike other kings in the surrounding nations, David ascribed to God the attributes that were normally used to speak of the monarch. He said, “Yours, O LORD, are the greatness, the power, the glory, the victory, and the majesty; for all that is in the heavens and on the earth is yours; yours is the kingdom, O LORD, and you are exalted as head above all” (1 Chronicles 29:11).
The second notable thing was that David acknowledged that ultimately, the people needed to thank God and not the king for everything they had. He said, “But who am I, and what is my people, that we should be able to make this freewill offering? For all things come from you, and of your own have we given you” (1 Chronicles 29: 14).
To use current church terminology, David’s prayer referred to stewardship, the recognition that, as Psalm 24 puts it, “The earth is the LORD’s and all that is in it” and that therefore we are both users and custodians of it.
The word “stewardship” comes from an Old English expression, “sty ward,” that meant “keeper of the pigs.” Eventually it came to refer to anyone who had responsibility for the estates or properties of another.
It may be surprising, therefore, that the word, originally used for a pig keeper, later became a proper name for a royal British family: the Stuarts. But as King David’s prayer shows, he would have understood that. Even kings are only temporary agents for the guardianship of God’s world.
In the church, we often use the word stewardship to refer to how much money we give to our congregation’s budget, and that is part of it—indeed the part that we’re focusing on this week—but the biblical sense of stewardship is larger than that. It involves how we use everything God has provided for us, including our planet and environment, our talents, our time, our ability to think and to feel and even our lives themselves. And it is based in gratitude for God’s gifts. It would be a minting error to think any less.
In an issue of Playboy appearing in the early 1980s, a beautiful young woman named Susie Scott was the centerfold. (By the way, I didn’t know that from seeing that particular issue of Playboy, but from some other articles I happened to read about Susie…with no pictures!) She spent the next 10 years doing modeling, acting and promotional work for the magazine, making a good living and enjoying the kind of celebrity that often attaches itself to that lifestyle. In 1988, after one failed marriage, Susie married Aspen, Colorado, attorney Joe Krabacher, and settled down to enjoy a life of comfortable wealth. For a time Susie was a partner in an antique store and a sushi bar.
But then, a little over 11 years ago, Susie happened to see a TV documentary on orphans in Mongolia, and she felt that she ought to do something to help. That’s when a friend of hers said she ought to consider Haiti, because it was much poorer than Mongolia and almost in the back yard of the United States. So Susie soon sold her other businesses and traveled to Haiti, where she asked a taxi driver to take her to where “the poor people are.” He drove her to a shantytown and then quickly sped off. There, a family of 17 took her in for the night, and Susie learned firsthand the plight of many people in that country, which is one of the world’s poorest.
Susie later told a reporter about that first visit to Haiti: “I knew I had been born that day.” She went on to say that she completely committed herself to Christ when she started working in Haiti. Since then, with her husband as a partner, Susie launched the Foundation for Worldwide Mercy and Sharing, an organization dedicated to serving the children of Haiti. The foundation now operates six schools, five orphanages and a hospital ward for abandoned children. Susie’s group feeds, clothes, educates and nurses close to 2,000 children on an ongoing basis.
Susie Krabacher has not merely set all this up. She spends up to half of each year there herself, nursing sick children, and helping in every way she can. Along the way, she has contracted lice, scabies and mange, and has been treated for encephalitis. She has also been threatened by gangs and troubled by bureaucrats, but she has stuck it out, and has won the respect of the local people of Haiti and of the Haitian government.
Susie’s is a stewardship story. In terms of money, Susie and Joe Krabacher fund the administration, publicity and travel expenses of the foundation out of their own pockets. The operating expenses come from donations, some of which come because of Susie’s unique personal story and her Playboy background—which shows that in God’s economy, transformation is always possible and nothing is ever wasted. But it is also a stewardship story in that Susie was able to see that not only her money, but her position of privilege, her celebrity and her life experience itself were treasures on loan from God, and she put them to use in a way that honors Christ.
None of us likely has the same resources Susie Krabacher does, but all of us have the treasures God has given us. The worst minting error we can make is to think they are only for our personal use. But it is a correctable situation, and one we can start in motion by acknowledging that everything we have comes from God’s hand.
This week you will receive a letter from Rich Fritsche, our Stewardship Chairperson, and me inviting you to share your commitment to our ministry and mission in 2006. I trust you will prayerfully consider your response and, as you acknowledge that everything we have comes from God’s hand, and remember the bountiful blessings which you have received from our benevolent God, that you will—with “an attitude of gratitude”—share generously in your gifts of presence and prayers; time, talents, and service…and of your financial resources.
+ + + + + + + + + +
PRAYER
Generous God, whatever we give to you is already yours. You entrust us with so much abundance; accept whatever we commit to you in the days ahead as signs of our love for you and our desire to serve you. You alone are Lord of our lives. It is already so; make it so even more for us, day by day. Amen.
+ + + + + + + + + +